Why Analytics Aren’t “Too Businessy” for the Church

Let’s be honest —
The word analytics can feel cold. Corporate. Businessy. Maybe even out of place in a church setting.

But here’s the truth: analytics, when used well, are simply a way to listen deeply and lead more faithfully. They’re not about spreadsheets — they’re about shepherding.

Modern ministry requires both spiritual wisdom and practical insight.

From Finance to the Fellowship Hall

Before Kingdom Metrics, I came from the world of finance — specifically analytics and customer experience. Years ago, I was part of a nationwide rollout for a platform designed to understand one key thing:

Why are people loyal to a product or company… and why are they not?

It was about more than metrics. We were identifying promoters — people who passionately told others about the brand — and detractors — those who quietly disengaged.

And as I dug into this method, something clicked:

This sounds a lot like evangelism.

Why do people share Christ with others? What impact has He had on their lives? Why do they invite friends to church? These are deeply spiritual questions — and they map closely to what businesses were trying to understand about loyalty and storytelling.

Evangelism often starts with relationships and personal impact.

Fast-Forward: Same Method, New Mission

A decade later, I found myself using that same methodology — but this time for a church. We surveyed over 1,300 attenders to find out:

Why do people recommend this church to others? Why do some hesitate?

What we discovered was powerful.

Yes, we heard what you’d expect:

We love the music.
The pastor’s messages are meaningful.
It’s a great place for my kids.

But we also heard things that could only be revealed by slicing the data by age and demographic. That’s where the gold was.

Data revealed that loyalty drops with younger generations.

The Generational Divide

When we looked at the data across age cohorts, here’s what stood out:

Boomers were the most loyal group in the church.
Millennials and Gen Z were the least loyal — and the most likely to leave quietly.

That’s a wake-up call.

If your church is only filled with aging attenders, and not engaging the next generation, there’s a natural expiration date approaching.

And here’s something even more specific:
Boomers often loved things Millennials found off-putting.

Take politics from the pulpit, for example. Boomers saw it as bold and grounded. But Millennials? They saw it as polarizing, even alienating. And because younger generations are comfortable switching churches, they do — often without saying a word.

Younger families are looking for connection, not controversy.

Data That Points to Decisions

This is where analytics shine. They don’t just reveal pain points — they illuminate pathways.

In this case, the data told us exactly what younger families were craving:

Authentic, meaningful fellowship
Someone to greet them, connect with them, follow up
Diversity — in friendships, in thinking, in background
A pastor who’s available and responsive
A church where they feel heard

None of that sounds like a corporate playbook. It sounds like Acts 2.

Authentic community is what younger generations are seeking.

This Is Where Leadership Takes the Baton

Once the data is on the table, it’s time for leadership to discern:

Are we aligned with our mission?
Are we reaching the people we say we’re here to serve?
Are there blind spots we haven’t seen until now?

Whether your mission is focused on caring for the aging population or reaching young families, analytics gives you clarity. It allows you to listen intentionally and respond purposefully.

Analytics Isn’t Business — It’s What You Already Do

We all analyze every day.

When your child says their stomach hurts — you ask questions.
When your spouse seems off — you look for clues and respond.
When your car won’t start — you troubleshoot.

Analytics is just a structured way of listening.
It’s not about numbers — it’s about people.

Real listening is the foundation of effective leadership.

A Free Gift to the Church

At Kingdom Metrics, we offer this kind of church-wide survey 12 times a year — completely free. No sales pitch. No pressure. Just a ministry to help churches understand the heart of their people and make decisions that matter.

If that sounds helpful to you, we’d love to talk.

📩 Reach out to us here
🌐 www.kingdommetrics.com

Let’s build churches that truly listen — and lead with love.

Because listening well isn’t a business strategy.
It’s discipleship.

Read on Substack →